Skip to main content

AI Valuations Explained: Accuracy, Errors, and What Agents Should Tell Clients

Written by Coach Emily on . Posted in Uncategorized.

Learn how to explain AI home valuation tools like Zillow’s Zestimate to clients, address accuracy concerns, and position yourself as the trusted expert.

The Line Every Agent Hears (and How to Handle It Like a Pro)

If you’re a real estate agent—especially new to the field—you’ve already had this conversation:

“But Zillow says my house is worth $XXX…”

It’s one of those moments that can make you freeze. A confident client quoting a Zestimate like it’s gospel, while you’re standing there with local comps, your pricing strategy, and your expertise ready to go.

And you’re wondering: How do I explain the gap without sounding defensive?

I’ve coached hundreds of agents through this exact scenario. And the truth is: you don’t need to battle AI valuations — you need to understand how they work, why they miss, and how to communicate their role to clients clearly.

In this blog, I’ll walk you through:

  • How accurate AVMs (Automated Valuation Models) really are
  • Why AI valuation tools get it wrong (and when they work well)
  • A coaching-based framework to help you confidently explain these tools
  • Stories and data to help you regain trust when clients rely on algorithms
  • Exactly what to say when a Zestimate derails your pricing conversation

Let’s break it down together — just like I would on a coaching call.

What Are AVMs (Automated Valuation Models)?

Let’s start with the basics. Tools like Zillow’s Zestimate, Redfin Estimate, HouseCanary, and CoreLogic are all AVMs — AI-powered algorithms that estimate home values using public data like:

  • Square footage
  • Tax records
  • Sale history
  • Lot size
  • Nearby sales
  • Neighborhood-level trends
  • Sometimes: school ratings, walkability, and even crime reports

They’re fast, accessible, and often used by buyers and sellers to “get a ballpark.”

But here’s the key: AVMs are trained on data — not context.

They don’t walk through the home. They don’t know that you upgraded the kitchen with marble counters and Wolf appliances last year. They don’t recognize that your lot backs to a greenbelt while your neighbor’s doesn’t.

AVMs offer a starting point — not a strategy.

How Accurate Are AI Valuations?

This is where things get murky — and where your ability to explain nuance will make or break client trust.

Let’s look at the data:

  • Zillow reports a 1.83% median error rate for on-market homes — meaning their estimate is within about 2% of the sale price, half the time.
  • For off-market homes, that error jumps to 7% — and in some areas, it spikes to 20%–40%.
  • MIT researchers found AVMs are only 63% accurate in real-world applications.
  • University of Florida studies show machine learning reduces error by 68% over traditional models — but still can’t match human appraisal judgment.
  • Only 40% of U.S. homes can be reliably valued by AVMs alone, according to HouseCanary.

So yes — they’re getting better. But they’re far from perfect.

And when they’re wrong, the damage is real. Just ask the seller whose Zestimate priced them $150,000 out of reach of buyers — or the buyer who overpaid in a slowing market because the AI didn’t see the shift coming.

Where AI Tools Get It Wrong (And Why It Matters)

Here’s the pattern I see across agents I coach nationwide: AI tools miss for specific reasons, and those reasons follow predictable categories.

1. Location Bias

AVMs work best where there are tons of similar homes and recent comps. In rural areas, non-disclosure states, or neighborhoods with few sales, accuracy drops fast.

“The more ‘cookie-cutter’ the comps, the better the estimate.”

2. Unique Properties

Custom builds, luxury homes, architectural anomalies, and upgrades outside the norm? AVMs don’t know how to weight them.

They reward “average.” You sell “exceptional.”

3. Rapid Market Changes

AI lags behind real-world shifts. If your market’s heating up fast or slowing down, the AVM won’t catch it until after the comps close — sometimes months later.

4. Demographic and Ethical Gaps

This one’s important: multiple studies show that AI valuations are less accurate in majority-Black and Latino neighborhoods, raising equity concerns.

5. Missing Human Nuance

AI doesn’t feel the vibe of a street, the value of a school district, or how that bonus room layout changes everything for a buyer.

Real Stories to Help You Educate Clients

I always encourage agents to keep a few stories ready. Not to scare clients away from tech — but to show the full picture.

Spencer Rascoff’s Zestimate Fail

Even the former CEO of Zillow sold his home for 40% less than the Zestimate. Proof that even the creators can’t fully control the model.

Carlsbad, CA Analysis

A local team tracked 95 home sales. Zestimates were wrong on all 95 — sometimes by over $190,000.

Virginia Overpricing Case

In Lake Monticello, VA, agents tested 21 homes. 17 had Zestimates that were significantly off. One sold 61% below the estimate.

Stories like these help clients realize the limitations — without you having to be the “bad guy.”

The ACCURACY Framework: How to Explain AI Valuations With Confidence

Here’s a coaching tool you can use right away: the ACCURACY™ framework.

Use it in listing presentations, pricing conversations, and buyer education.

A — Analyze the Tool’s Source

Ask: where is this estimate coming from? How recent is the data? Does it show a confidence score or range?

If the tool doesn’t show its math, be cautious.

C — Cross-Reference Other Sources

Pull the Zestimate, Redfin Estimate, Realtor.com, HouseCanary. Compare ranges.

Then layer in your CMA, recent showings, appraisal insights, and buyer feedback.

C — Calculate a Range, Not a Number

Never deliver a single price point. Say:

“Based on all sources and the comps, I believe your home sits between $X and $Y.”

This gives you room to adapt based on interest and feedback.

U — Understand Local Limitations

Be ready to explain what AI gets wrong in your market.
 For example:

“In our area, AVMs don’t factor in lake access or view quality, which can swing values by 10% or more.”

R — Recommend Appraisal Backups When Needed

Especially with unique or high-value homes, always encourage third-party support:

“If we’re within 5% of a pricing decision, let’s bring in a pre-listing appraisal to firm it up.”

A — Articulate the Value of Human Context

Educate clients that you’re the translator — the one who combines data, trends, and buyer behavior in real time.

C — Continue Evaluating AVMs Over Time

Stay sharp. Watch how accurate AVMs are in your local sales. Share findings in newsletters or social posts.

Y — Your Role Isn’t Optional

AI can estimate. You interpret, explain, and guide.

That’s not going away.

What to Say When Clients Quote Zillow

Here’s a simple, respectful script:

“Zillow’s estimate is based on public data — it’s a great place to start. But it doesn’t see what I’ve seen walking through your home, or what buyers are responding to this month. In our market, those numbers can swing by 15–20%. Let me show you how we can use it alongside real comps to make the best decision.”

Simple. Validating. Clear.

FAQs: What Agents and Clients Ask About AI Valuations

Q: How accurate are AVMs compared to appraisals?
A: For on-market homes, they can be close. But for unique, luxury, or off-market properties, appraisals are typically more accurate — especially when pricing matters most.

Q: Why do agents push back on Zestimates?
A: Because agents often see how wrong they are in practice. Especially in markets with limited sales or unique properties, the algorithm misses key factors.

Q: Should I include AI valuations in my listing presentations?
A: Yes — but explain them as one piece of the valuation picture. Position yourself as the expert who interprets all the data, not just the flashiest number.

Q: Can AVMs help new agents look more knowledgeable?
A: Absolutely. Use them to start conversations, back up comps, or show price movement — but always with a clear explanation of their limits.

Q: What do I do if a client insists on listing at the Zestimate price?
A: Show side-by-side comps, share stories or error rates in your market, and set expectations. If they still won’t budge, consider your pricing strategy or listing agreement limits.

Additional Resources

Want to go deeper into this topic or build more confidence around AI tools?

Final Thoughts

AVMs aren’t going away. And you shouldn’t fear them.

You’re not competing with AI — you’re using it with context. You’re the voice clients need to make sense of the noise.

So the next time someone says “But Zillow says…,” take a deep breath and lean in.

You’ve got this.

And if you want help building your confidence with AI tools, pricing strategies, or client conversations — DM me your story. Let’s make sure algorithms don’t outshine the expertise that only real agents bring.

—
Emily Terrell
#1 Real Estate Coach & AI Speaker at Tom Ferry
www.coachemilyterrell.com | @coachemilyterrell

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *